The Great Gender Divergence

The Great Gender Divergence

Share this post

The Great Gender Divergence
The Great Gender Divergence
"The Making of the Modern Muslim State" by Malika Zeghal (REVIEW)

"The Making of the Modern Muslim State" by Malika Zeghal (REVIEW)

Alice Evans's avatar
Alice Evans
Mar 11, 2025
∙ Paid
16

Share this post

The Great Gender Divergence
The Great Gender Divergence
"The Making of the Modern Muslim State" by Malika Zeghal (REVIEW)
1
3
Share

95% of Middle Eastern Muslim-majority polities enshrine a state-preferred religion. Among Muslim-majority polities worldwide, that figure is also pretty high - 71%. But for non-Muslim majority polities? Just 45%. What explains this great religious divergence? Why are Muslim, especially MENA, countries more likely enshrine religious laws?

Is this an inevitable feature of Islamic states, or was it enabled by a particular set of circumstances? If so, which? Hypotheses vary! Existing scholarship on the Global Islamic Revival tends to focus on country-specific factors – Egypt’s economic stagnation, Turkey’s religious associations, Iran’s religious authoritarianism, Sahelian state weakness, Pakistani return migration from the Gulf, repression in Uzbekistan, Indonesian’s resistance to secular schooling. But could there be a common thread?

Let me strongly recommend Malika Zeghal’s new book, “The Making of the Modern Muslim State: Islam and Governance in the Middle East and North Africa”.

Seriously, it will rock your priors!

Graph I made, using Zeghal 2024, Table 8

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Alice Evans
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share