Quick poll. Modernisation Theory proposes that as societies become more affluent, they undergo a fundamental shift in values. Once people’s basic wants are satisfied, they become more secular, scientific and open-minded. Economic development is thought to encourage secularism - as in Latin America.
The USA seems to be more religious than Northern Europe. That's based solely on my perceptions as a Brit watching their culture and politics. Any ideas why. Or is it a misconception?
According to https://religionnews.com/2014/12/11/1940s-america-wasnt-religious-think-rise-fall-american-religion/ the USA was not particularly religious in the 1940s but underwent a religious revival during the cold war. 'Christianity vs Communism' was a real theme. I think the theme of 'Islam vs the West plays out precisely the same way many places, which makes you wonder if it is the existence of an external enemy and the belief that we are involved in a ideological war that matters, and not prosperity.
"In Turkey in 2001, highly educated individuals were more secular. But that pattern does not hold in the rest of the Middle East and North Africa."
I would not use Turkey as a secularisation example due to its unique history. When the Ottoman Empire was replaced by the Republic in 1923/24, the extreme secularisation efforts imposed upon it, especially for the urban part, probably led to the 2001 statistic above.
That's precisely my point. There are lots of idiosyncracies, mediated by more than economics. And what holds in one year in Turkey may not hold in Turkey later on. And I say that top-down secularisers imposed reforms.
The USA seems to be more religious than Northern Europe. That's based solely on my perceptions as a Brit watching their culture and politics. Any ideas why. Or is it a misconception?
According to https://religionnews.com/2014/12/11/1940s-america-wasnt-religious-think-rise-fall-american-religion/ the USA was not particularly religious in the 1940s but underwent a religious revival during the cold war. 'Christianity vs Communism' was a real theme. I think the theme of 'Islam vs the West plays out precisely the same way many places, which makes you wonder if it is the existence of an external enemy and the belief that we are involved in a ideological war that matters, and not prosperity.
"In Turkey in 2001, highly educated individuals were more secular. But that pattern does not hold in the rest of the Middle East and North Africa."
I would not use Turkey as a secularisation example due to its unique history. When the Ottoman Empire was replaced by the Republic in 1923/24, the extreme secularisation efforts imposed upon it, especially for the urban part, probably led to the 2001 statistic above.
That's precisely my point. There are lots of idiosyncracies, mediated by more than economics. And what holds in one year in Turkey may not hold in Turkey later on. And I say that top-down secularisers imposed reforms.