27 Comments
User's avatar
Gerard Roland's avatar

Very interesting. I like that you put intergroup conflict at the center and not division of labor. The fight against patriarchy is maybe one of the defining moments of our epoch.

Alice Evans's avatar

Yes, absolutely, I think there's been far too much focus on the division of labour.

Whereas if we step back and look at the emergence of human cooperation and modern states, we realise that this was so often a military and fraternal endeavour.

Alice Evans's avatar

Further, if we consider countries like Thailand, Myanmar, Indonesia, Russia, China, and South korea, it’s clear that the division of labour can weaken, with high female employment, but organisations and institutions remain dominated by men

Forseti's avatar

You seem to be focusing on a division of labour in this very post, though, as far as I understand — the monopolisation of martial activities by men.

D Baer's avatar

Actually the fight against feminism is the defining moment of our epoch.

Jon's avatar

Though it sounds as if we'll have to stop fighting one another before the fight against patriarchy can be won.

D Baer's avatar

Be careful what you wish for. Without the patriarchy, humanity, would quickly descend back to the jungle or to faux-liberal sh!tholes like San Fransicko. What we really need to fight is feminist ideological indoctrination.

Jon's avatar

No, it isn't.

Wafa Hakim Orman's avatar

It would be interesting to see how and why misogyny evolves the way it does across different cultures and contexts.

To use the examples here: patriarchy is ultimately about male control and dominance over women, and control of resources. Does that happen through male fraternal groups that encourage mistrust of women and view them as a source of temptation? Or through family/kinship networks that venerate motherhood and women in their maternal role? Or a more condescending view, where women are viewed similarly to prized livestock?

Seclusion of menstruating women also doesn't manifest the same way everywhere. In some places women are secluded in a hut. In others, they remain in the same house but are kept out of the kitchen. In others, they live a normal life except they are kept away from religious rituals. (Among friends we often joked that a week-long break from the kitchen was probably something women came up with and happily enforce, it makes for a pretty nice respite!)

D Baer's avatar

Ditto misandry and particulary it’s political forms of which feminism is the most pernicious Post Modern form.

Michael Frank Martin's avatar

This is compelling, and a wonderful complement to Sarah Blaffer Hrdy's work, which I have admired for many decades. Hrdy looks earlier in evolutionary history to understand how human cooperation (and language) evolved through alloparenting. This feels like a natural contintuation of Hrdy's perspective through the scaling up of kin-based clans into cities and states.

Amit Sharma's avatar

Great observations as always, well done!

Stefano's avatar

Interesting essay, but there's a few assumptions, and perhaps a touch of man hating, which is cringe.

Firstly, surplus isn't a prerequisite for predation. Predation happens regardless, while surplus requires security, unless predation is absent. I'm going to guess predation occurs among hunter gatherers, nomads and herders alike in the literature.

Secondly, you make it sound like men had a choice to include or exclude women from warfare. Like seriously, the evidence from reading your essay is ideology trumps reality: if every fight in every culture and group everywhere is undertaken by men, as you cite, perhaps there's a reason if warrior women are the exception to the rule? And if defense is dependent on men's willingness to die for the community, promoting attributes to this effect, has its logic.

Thirdly, I love anthropology, but all these tribes observed in the studies cited, they didn't invent electricity and create modernity or complex societies.

Fourthly, there's an assumption all these worldwide societies and religions (and their texts) are all lying scoundrels for portraying and casting women in a negative light, even though they also portray women in a positive light, yes? If cultures far and wide with little contact with one another all reached the same conclusion, then ... ?

What is the patriarchy? I've met a few patriarchs in my life, but very few, and none in the West.

Savannah's avatar

It is always Alice Evans articles that the most sensitive men come into the comments to shadow-box arguments the author did not make (surplus as a prerequisite to predation, societies choosing to exclude women from warfare is “bad,” small societies are automatically representative of human nature).

But the “fourthly” says it all - if world religions say women are evil, then that must be the truth.

Jason Hubbard's avatar

I feel like there is a hole here for prehistoric or even ancient historic cultures, as there is increasing archeological evidence for women warriors. There is a bias effect of only studying living cultures, or cultures that were living when they were studied and entered the anthropological record. Which is namely that they survived, and none of them were isolated from the ancient world.

So for example with New Guinea, New Guinea was not some isolated island never touched by ancient civilizations, New Guinea was clearly known about by the imperial thalassocracies of the region. One way or the other, most of these living cultures have had multiple contacts with advanced agrarian cultures in their regions. So there isn't really a good basis to claim that their practices and attitudes regarding women remain uninfluenced by these advanced agrarian cultures. There's a survivors bias for these cultures of having to survive attack from the advanced agrarian cultures they encounter mounting military responses over resources, or to claim valuable territory, or even to capture or exploit the women. And yes, sure, ancient Javanese sailors probably had difficulty penetrating the interior or New Guinea, but coastal cultures can transmit cultural ideas to the interior.

But by the archeological record, there's a growing reference library of ancient women being included as warriors in highly militant cultures. There's a very real possibility that there is a bias in the study of living cultures produced by successful patriarchal cultures suppressing less patriarchal cultures in the specifics of history. So for example, if the Persians rather than Romans had succeeded in dominating the Mediterranean, then perhaps there would have been more survivors of warrior womanhood; the Romans were particularly and aggressively more patriarchal than many of their contemporaries, and leveraged their views by conquest.

That would challenge the chain of surplus -> predation -> military fraternity; many bronze age cultures included women in their military 'fraternities.' Basically I'm suggesting that the fraternal militaries outcompeted at the advanced agrarian level, and that surviving living cultures either adopted or adapted as a result.

Gabrielle Sorensen's avatar

This is no doubt a real phenomenon, but do complex societies emerge because of male coalitions, or do male coalitions emerge naturally when a society reaches a certain level of organization and population size? Among full-fledged civilizations, there doesn’t seem to be as much correlation between martial behaviour and male dominance, with examples like the Mongols and Spartans versus Chinese and Athenians.

D Baer's avatar

Complex civilizations emerge because of male sexuality. It's no accident that Musk named his EV line S3XY. It's also no accident that Liz Holmes is, arguably, Musk's finest counterpart (deep sarcasm intended) in the civilization builder category. If one wants to assess the civilization building capacity of women all one needs to do is to look that at shameless corruption that is Women's Studies or at the cesspool of the Social Sciences beneath female demographic domination and oxymoronic ideological 'leadership'. Unlike men, women do not have to repress their sexuality and express it in great works because women already rule the sexual world. Because women have no biological imperative to do great things, Bonobo behavior/female (feminine) dominance will never create complex civilizations that can compete with the complex civilizations built and run by men.

Scapegoating the patriarchy is so foolish. Paglia said: "If women were in charge of history, we'd all still be living in grass huts." We should send feminists back to their favorite historical abodes so that men can work and play with wise women who are appropriately grateful, respectful, interesting, and even humorous.

Gabrielle Sorensen's avatar

I think you would be better off if you deleted your X account.

D Baer's avatar

Actually, you’d be better off argument-wise had I never read Camille Paglia’s Sexual Personae. FYI: I don’t use X but I’m glad that ole Elon blew up the totalitarian alt-left Twitterdom. The Woke-feminist mind virus certainly needs to get cleared if anyone is gonna be able to think at all.

QN's avatar
Oct 23Edited

"The Christian Bible, Muslim Quran, Hebrew Torah, as well as Buddhist and Hindu scriptures all blame women for tempting and manipulating men."

No. The Quran presents a fundamentally different paradigm. The only example I can think of I can think of is Joseph and the governor's wife (Zuleikha).

She fails entirely to seduce him. Rather than a trope of passive male manipulation, the Quran frames it as an abuse of power over an enslaved young man, which Joseph resists out of devotion to God, ultimately choosing imprisonment over compromise.

The Quran culminates not in villainizing women, but in the woman publicly admitting her fault and fully vindicating Joseph’s integrity ("Now the truth has become evident. It was I who sought to seduce him, and indeed, he is of the truthful" - 12:51).

Also in Sufi poetics Zuleikha after that statement becomes a saint, becomes widowed and ends up marrying Joseph, after he is released from prison.

Furthermore, in the story of the Fall, at no point in the Quran does Prophet Adam blame Eve. Satan whispers to them, and when they seek forgiveness, they pointedly repent together as equals in moral agency:

"Qālā rabbanā ẓalamnā anfusanā wa-in lam taghfir lanā wa-tarḥamnā lanakūnanna mina al-khāsirīn."

("They both said: 'Our Lord, we have wronged ourselves, and if You do not forgive us and have mercy upon us, we will surely be among the losers.'" — 7:23)

Very far from blaming women for the downfall of men, the Quran emphasizes individual accountability and mutual responsibility. (Note Adam doesn't even blame Satan - he blames himself).

Brett Reynolds's avatar

Whyte (1978 *The status of women in preindustrial societies*) considered two highly relevant hypothese across 93 societies:

-Institutionalized male solidarity predicts lower female status: not supported

-Constant warfare predicts lower female status: not supported

1978 was quite a while ago and the research landscape is probably quite different, but you'd want to check these at least.

Also, have you looked at Cailin O'Connor's *The origins of unfairness*?

Let's INDUlge's avatar

These male fraternal alliances become even more intelligible when viewed alongside the continued practice of purdah. Misogyny not only seek to prevent romantic relationships between men and women from flourishing, but it also makes sure to minimise interaction between the two genders more broadly. By restricting such interactions, patriarchal structures reinforce male solidarity, restrict women’s mobility and social autonomy, and preserve the gendered hierarchies upon which patriarchy thrives.

Areeb's avatar

What about the warlike English or Germanic people? Is it the case that they suppressed romantic love? You read Shakespeare and there is a lot of war but there is also romance. Is it that early Anglo Saxon during their conquests were more like what you described, but once they were a settled agrarian society attitudes started to change (despite foreign wars still happening)?

Early American settlers also strike me as pretty militaristic and there is probably a lot of written material on that

Coriolis's avatar

This is a very nice writeup as usual, but i think it's a little too unaware of it's overwhelming focus on small scale societies. Once you pull out to e.g. Romans or Persians or Chinese, the correlations with wealth in particular tend to run the other way. Which is sensible in your picture -if you have nothing, you don't need to defend it, and if you have a lot, you come up with more sophisticated ways to defend it that are less reliant on the small scale warband.

All in all, i see this as a quite positive picture of humanity - warfare forces us into extreme patriarchy because that is seemingly the simplest defensive configuration. But as societies get larger and complex, other ways of ensuring loyalty become feasible. Not to mention that different aspects of war become important as technology improves and technical knowledge of e.g. sailing becomes important.

Alice Evans's avatar

Hello Coriolis, as the author of this piece, I am very aware that I have intentionally focused on small-scale societies. Please stay tuned for the next essay on empire. :-)

Coriolis's avatar

No i know, i have a lot of respect for your work

Jon's avatar

Fascinating. Is the military fraternities step in the argument based on Van Vugt's male warrior hypothesis?